Why Great Investors Are Blind
Get smarter on investing, business, and personal finance in 5 minutes.
If you were forwarded this email, click here to subscribe for freeThis newsletter is adapted from a previous video Drew Cohen did on Why Great Investors Are Blind.
Every great investor shares one trait in common, and that trait is a kind of willful blindness, a deliberate choice to ignore certain things happening in the world.
Warren Buffett is fond of saying that if you have an IQ of 160, you should give 30 of those points away, since you do not need them to be a good investor.
Being genuinely intelligent actually raises the risk of doing something genuinely foolish.
A highly intelligent person tends to be good at noticing everything going on in the world, connecting different data points and facts, and weaving them into a new, convincing story.
That self-built narrative can push an investor to avoid investing altogether, to sell existing positions, or to wait indefinitely on the sidelines.
These are patterns I see constantly as a financial advisor, and the worst mistakes tend to come from trying to outsmart the market and believing it is possible to know what happens next.
The Illusion of Macro Prediction.
History does not need to be revisited far to find plenty of reasons not to invest, including things happening right now.
At the start of this decade, COVID shut down the global economy in 2020, and unemployment climbed higher than it had during the Great Recession.
In 2021, the market staged a monster rally after that shutdown, which made plenty of investors wonder why anyone would buy in at that point?
In 2022, the Federal Reserve began raising interest rates and cutting stimulus, right as the money supply started to contract, another moment that looked like a poor time to invest.
More recently, there have been multiple wars in the Middle East, high oil prices, and tariffs introduced in April 2025 that were widely expected to hurt the economy badly.
In just the past several years alone, the market has seen 4 corrections and almost 3 bear markets, and that count leaves out the many other stretches where the market fell considerably further or simply looked frightening without anything bad actually following.
When someone is genuinely intelligent and well connected to markets and the news, risk appears to be everywhere.
One of the most common conversations with clients starts with a question such as whether tariffs are something to be scared of, "since new import taxes can invite retaliation and raise the deadweight loss businesses absorb by spending money on things they were already doing well, simply to cover a larger expense base."
A client might just as easily ask about an oil-producing region at war and whether prices could keep climbing as related oil output falls.
All of these concerns can be true at once, and that is exactly what makes this part of the job so difficult, because a genuinely smart person who sees every one of these forces in play can build an extremely convincing narrative and fall prey to narrative fallacy.
The more data that gets poured into a narrative, and the more it gets illustrated, the more real it starts to feel.
An advisor who responds to a detailed, well-supported case with a simple "we do not know" can sound distinctly less sharp than the person laying out every risk, even when that uncertainty is the honest and accurate answer.
As strange as it sounds, the hardest thing for a smart investor to do is practice humility, recognizing that putting a name and a label on a negative-sounding macro factor does not mean the ultimate outcome is actually known.
So many variables feed into the global economy that many long-term investors, Warren Buffett very much included, hold the view that macro events cannot reliably be predicted.
There may be a small subset of investors, Stanley Druckenmiller among them, who can be genuinely skilled at forecasting currency moves, but that is a narrow and rare talent most people simply do not have.
Someone who truly does have that ability has little use for outside advice and can go trade currencies directly.
The larger point most people need to understand is that risk existing in the world, by itself, says nothing about how that risk actually unfolds.
The more front and center something is, the more an investor risks over-weighting it, a pattern known as saliency bias.
Saliency bias means that the more obvious something is, and the more it shows up repeatedly in the news, the more people tend to weigh it and think about it.
The common result of that bias is that people choose to wait before investing, which history shows is typically the biggest mistake an investor can make.
This dynamic shows up constantly with new clients who arrive with a large amount of uninvested money, since the question immediately becomes how much to invest today versus how much to invest later.
The right answer depends on the individual, but the historical record shows that about two-thirds of the time, the best decision is to invest everything all at once in a lump sum instead of spreading it out over time.
Whether to invest a client's money all at once also depends on more than just the amount of funds currently on hand; it depends on how much cash flow that person is generating throughout the year as well.
Someone who is saving a large amount of money, is young, and has many years of saving still ahead tends to be a much stronger candidate for investing more today, if not all of it, instead of waiting.
Plenty of people will want to criticize a decision to invest everything immediately, but the historical record shows the bigger mistake has been sitting on the sidelines.
There has never been a 20-year period in historical stock market pricing data that produced a negative real return.
A negative return over 20 years may not sound like a particularly exciting or lucrative bar to clear, but it illustrates that the longer an investor's timeframe is, the less risky investing actually becomes.
A 1-year or 2-year stretch, on the other hand, can go almost anywhere.
There is zero way to know whether the market will be down 20% by the end of this year.
There is, however, far more confidence available about what tends to happen over the long term, and when client portfolios and the underlying businesses inside their ETFs and individual stocks are examined, that confidence extends to the long-term trajectory of those businesses specifically.
Focus on the Business, Not the Stock Price.
Consider one stock that, over the course of 6 months, has been up 40% and down 40%, while the underlying business itself barely changed at all.
Seeing those price swings in advance would not have changed the original purchase decision, nor would the outcome have been especially surprising.
That example shows just how much of a game trying to guess short-term price movement can become.
Over the long run, far more confidence is available in a business that keeps adding value for a large number of customers, stays profitable, and reinvests that profit at strong rates of return, since a business like that tends to become a much bigger business over time.
This is the point Warren Buffett returns to constantly: a stock investment should be thought of as an investment in a business.
It is a lesson worth remembering even for an advisor, since there are moments of watching a stock price fall and instinctively thinking something looks wrong, right up until a look at the business results shows nothing in them that actually supports that reaction.
A genuine test of whether an investor actually understands what they own is whether they get rattled when the stock price drops.
Treating a falling price as information about what action to take signals that the stock market has stopped being a servant and become a guide instead.
That idea goes back to chapter 8 of The Intelligent Investor and its analogy of Mr. Market, who shows up some days offering a low bid worth taking advantage of and other days offering a high bid worth selling into.
Most of the time, though, the better move is to ignore whatever Mr. Market is saying entirely and treat it as noise instead of real information bearing on an investment decision.
Patience and Temperament.
Part of the reason behind producing business-focused investment content, instead of content centered on short-term price moves, is to help clients make that same shift from watching the stock price to understanding the actual business.
One of the hardest things an investor has to do is be patient, and Warren Buffett, in addition to being regarded as one of the greatest investors of all time, has a gift for putting that idea into words.
Buffett describes the stock market as a mechanism for transferring money from the impatient to the patient.
It is an easy thing to say you want to be a long-term investor, and a much harder thing to actually do while watching a stock price move every week, every day, or even every minute after opening an investment account.
That kind of behavior and attitude does more than create unnecessary stress over the long term; it also raises the odds of doing something irrational, such as selling out of a position or shifting into a different business for reasons that have nothing to do with new analysis or an established investment philosophy, and everything to do with emotion.
One of the biggest differences separating good investors from mediocre ones is not intelligence but temperament.
There are plenty of stories involving widows or grandparents who bought a handful of stocks at some point and then genuinely forgot the account even existed.
Decades later, when that account is reopened, often while being handed down to grandchildren, it holds an extraordinary amount of money, sometimes in the many millions.
The part of those stories that tends to go unmentioned is that the person who left that money untouched was, quite literally, never thinking about it again.
That is the genuinely hard part of investing, especially for anyone interested in markets who watches stock prices all day and tracks every new risk as it forms.
Does it still make sense to hold a travel stock if a new regional war breaks out and oil prices move higher, since high oil prices could weigh on people's willingness to travel and book flights?
Maybe it does, but nobody actually knows for certain.
A large part of an advisor's role turns out to be reminding people of the limits of prediction, encouraging humility, and helping clients genuinely accept that nobody is going to know exactly what happens next.
Investing does not promise certainty.
Instead, the best available approach is to analyze and understand a business, or to get broad exposure to many different businesses through an ETF, and trust that a capitalist system built around continually solving problems and delivering value for people will eventually translate into the ability to monetize that value.
The Two Games of Investing.
There are 2 separate games to play in investing, and the first one is essentially trying to get one up on everyone else.
That means figuring out whether a business's results are going to come in better or worse than people currently expect, and whether there is a catalyst in the near term that the market is missing and that could cause a quick repricing.
Winning this first game means being correct on 2 separate things at once: the underlying analysis itself, and what the market currently expects to happen in the future.
Some people genuinely do get this right.
Identifying memory chips as a bottleneck in last year's AI buildout, back when Micron traded around $60 a share, worked out extremely well, since earnings and memory orders both ended up coming in far above what the market was expecting at the time.
The problem with investing this way comes down to 3 separate difficulties: these opportunities are hard to find in the first place, hard to time correctly even once found, and hard to size up against what the market is actually expecting.
The investors who do manage to get it right, and luck genuinely plays a role even when nobody likes admitting that, tend not to be able to reproduce that kind of result very often.
More often than not, finding one of these opportunities turns into a one-time event, and the next bet that same investor makes rarely turns out quite as well as the first one did.
Very few people actually have a strong long-term track record doing this inside the stock market.
The second game, and the one actually being played here, involves buying a stock and treating it as partial ownership of a business.
Playing this game means focusing on how much the business itself improves in value over time, with far less concern about what the stock price happens to be doing on any given day, since the daily price does not say much, if anything, about the actual value of the business.
The appeal of the second game is that it is a game where everyone involved can win.
There is no need to sell a stock to someone else at a higher price in order to make money, since the business itself can simply continue growing, which lets everyone invested in it make money alongside it.
That same logic scales up to the stock market as a whole, and it explains why the stock market has created such a tremendous amount of wealth over time.
The tricky part is that playing this game requires real patience.
An infamous statistic makes this point clearly: Peter Lynch's mutual fund track record while running the Magellan Fund produced a 29% annualized return, a genuinely phenomenal result by any measure.
It has been widely reported, though, that the average investor in that same fund earned only about 7%.
The gap between what Peter Lynch earned running the fund and what the average investor in the fund actually earned amounts to something close to an impatience tax.
The fund would put up a strong stretch of returns, investors would pile in chasing that performance, and then, almost without fail, the fund would go through a mediocre year or two, at which point those same investors would leave for something else, right before the fund went on to have another excellent year.
Those investors would then jump back in later, trying to catch the next run.
This is how a lot of people end up investing, whether they mean to or not, since they will own stocks that have not moved in a while, maybe sitting slightly down, and then watch other stocks that are up a lot and want to jump into those instead.
That kind of fad-based momentum trading is not a good way to invest, not statistically and not historically.
The reason investors do it anyway comes back to temperament, since doing nothing for a year, 2 years, or even several years is a genuinely hard thing to do.
Microsoft had more than a lost decade, a stretch beyond 10 years where the stock did not go anywhere, before it eventually delivered a very strong return afterward.
That example captures one of the trickier parts of investing: it is possible to be right about a stock and right about the underlying business and still have to wait a very long time before the market actually validates that view.
A correct thesis does tend to get validated eventually, though, and even when the market and other investors never fully wake up to how good a business actually is, the business itself can still force that realization through its own actions, continuing to buy back a large amount of stock over time.
AutoNation is a useful example here, since the company bought back more than 90% of its own stock.
Because of that, it did not matter much whether or not investors were enthusiastic about the business, since the company itself was consistently a buyer of its own stock, and that steady buying inadvertently pushed the stock price higher over time regardless.
There is sometimes a line of thinking that a business should be avoided simply because it is unpopular, on the theory that the market will never fully value it properly.
Even if that concern turns out to be true, the business itself can still take action, through stock repurchases or by issuing a dividend, that forces a revaluation.
Building Financial Resiliency.
The big takeaway from all of this is that being a long-term investor requires patience, and a few specific practices can make sustaining that patience considerably easier.
The first practice is doing financial planning well ahead of time, separating the funds actually needed to live on from the money genuinely allocated toward long-term investing.
Without a clear distinction between the 2, it becomes very likely that money needed for near-term living expenses ends up invested as well, which then creates added anxiety around every move in stock prices.
The second practice is not investing with margin, since it introduces considerably more risk.
Everyone's financial situation is different, and that has to be acknowledged, but adding margin into the mix generally creates a real risk of a complete wipeout.
A market decline of 50% is survivable without margin, since a portfolio can absorb a difficult stretch and eventually recover to trade higher than it did before, the way portfolios did after the financial crisis, and, over a much shorter window, during the COVID selloff as well.
People who lived through the financial crisis understand what that kind of drawdown genuinely feels like, and it is not an enjoyable experience to live through, even when the recovery eventually arrives.
Without margin, an investor is never a forced seller.
With margin, there is a real possibility of a margin call that forces liquidation of an entire portfolio, an event that can wipe out an investor, remove them from the market entirely, and leave no easy path back in.
The third practice is avoiding businesses carrying a large amount of debt.
Heavy debt makes a business considerably more fragile when it runs into the kinds of pressures that show up during an inevitable recession or broader economic slowdown, while businesses carrying less debt are better positioned to lean into those environments, keep serving customers as well as they can, and potentially take market share away from weaker competitors in the process.
Floor & Decor is a useful recent example, since one of its biggest competitors went bankrupt and Floor & Decor gained share as a direct result.
That outcome traced back to Floor & Decor's stronger financial position and its comparatively light debt load, which meant it did not have a large amount of debt sitting on its balance sheet that needed to be serviced, and having that kind of financial resiliency is another way a business can help an investor weather these periods with less emotional strain.
Why You Are Not a Fortune Teller.
In conclusion, it matters a great deal not to believe that anyone is a fortune teller, capable of knowing exactly how every geopolitical event is going to unfold or exactly how that event will affect the stock market, a portfolio, or an individual business.
That can be a genuinely tricky thing to accept, since some risks can appear obvious on their face, such as the idea that high oil prices will obviously slow down the broader economy.
The truth is that nobody actually knows, and nobody fully knows every other factor that could potentially respond to that same event in offsetting ways.
That is also what the track records of various investors have shown as well.
Most of the best investors are the ones who do not try to predict these kinds of short-term events, though they may take advantage of a related opportunity if certain businesses happen to be selling off cheaply, or if other businesses appear to be trading at exorbitant prices and worth selling.
What they are not doing is actively trying to guess how a given geopolitical event is going to impact their investing.
A belief like that can turn out correct some of the time, which is the most frustrating part of all, since getting it right occasionally can make it feel like a repeatable skill, when in practice it cannot be done reliably.
The single biggest mistake observed while managing other people's money is trading away the one thing history has reliably shown about stocks and businesses, which is that they tend to go up over time, in exchange for a belief about how a specific geopolitical event is going to affect a portfolio.
Client retirements and the money clients have saved up over time are not something to gamble with on a geopolitical call.
The actual goal is positioning a portfolio for the broadest possible range of circumstances, and in most of those circumstances, the market moves higher over time, which makes simply not being invested in the market the costlier mistake by far.
For More on Why Great Investors Are Blind, check out the video below.
YouTube FAQ
Nothing in this newsletter is investment advice nor should be construed as such. Contributors to the newsletter may own securities discussed. Furthermore, accounts contributors advise on may also have positions in companies discussed. Please see our full disclaimers here.