Skip to content

Stop Trying to Beat the Market

Get smarter on investing, business, and personal finance in 5 minutes.

If you were forwarded this email, click here to subscribe for free

This newsletter is adapted from a previous video Drew Cohen did on Stop Beating the Market.

This may not be the discussion one wants to have about their investing, but it is the one worth having anyway.

Beating the market means picking individual stocks that perform better than a market index over a given period, usually a year.

That benchmark is typically the S&P 500, or for a lower bar, an index like MSCI that weights more heavily toward international stocks, which have underperformed U.S. stocks for an extended stretch.

The S&P 500 is a difficult benchmark to beat.

In the first year alone, 65% of actively managed funds underperform it.

If we zoom out to a 10-year period, that figure rises to about 85%.

An individual investor attempting to beat the market is attempting something that 85% of investment professionals have failed to do over a decade.

That 85% figure actually understates the real rate of failure, because of selectivity bias in the underlying data.

Funds that performed so poorly that they shut down are, by definition, no longer around to be counted, so the data on actively managed fund performance excludes exactly the funds that failed the worst.

Once that omitted group is accounted for, the true underperformance rate is considerably higher than 85%.

An investor already deep into investing likely already knew that beating the market is difficult.

But the difficulty of beating the market is not actually the point of this discussion.

The point is what to focus on instead: what actually matters for an individual investor, and the process behind investing itself.

Focus on What Actually Matters.

Investing, for most people, serves one underlying purpose: having more money in the future, available at the moment it is actually needed.

Money that is not there when it is needed defeats the purpose of saving and investing it in the first place, which makes the timing of when money becomes available just as important as how much of it there eventually is.

Some people invest partly for the satisfaction of competing against professional money managers, treating it as something closer to a game.

That motivation is fine for a person with enough money held elsewhere that a 50% drawdown in an investment account would not actually affect their life.

Most people, however, do not have their financial life structured that way, which makes the objectives behind the investing matter a great deal.

Match Your Investments to When You Need the Money.

A younger investor may not yet have concrete financial objectives, but the money saved and invested today will meaningfully shape future wealth regardless.

An investor further along, managing a mortgage, children, a college tuition fund, or an upcoming home down payment, needs the money currently invested to match the timing of when it will actually be spent.

For money invested in stocks, a time horizon of at least 5 years is a reasonable minimum before that money is needed, and 10 years is a more conservative figure to use.

Three separate periods over the past century have seen stocks sit essentially flat for about a decade, and within each of those stretches, the market spent long periods down before recovering.

Consider a $500,000 balance earmarked for a home down payment.

If the market drops 30% before that money is spent and has not yet recovered, that balance falls to $350,000, not enough to complete the purchase.

The result is years of additional saving and waiting for the account to recover before the purchase becomes possible again, all while opportunity cost rises because the money had to be pulled out of a depressed market in the first place.

Avoiding that outcome means matching the duration of an investment to when the money will actually be spent.

Money needed in less than roughly 5 years, depending on individual circumstances, is often better held outside the stock market entirely, in shorter-duration assets such as fixed income.

That approach is not the most exciting advice, but it tends to produce better overall outcomes and considerably more peace of mind.

Money is eventually going to be spent, and at the moment it is spent, the goal is for it not to be sitting at a depressed valuation.

Any mismatch between an investment's time horizon and when the money is actually needed raises the odds of being forced to sell during a downturn, a genuinely bad outcome regardless of whether the underlying stock picks were beating the market up to that point.

Taxes are a further consideration tied to matching money to its purpose.

Short-term capital gains are generally worth avoiding where possible, and certain investments make more sense held inside a retirement account than inside an individual taxable account, depending on how that investment gets taxed.

The last factor often gets underweighted: a person's own emotional resilience and ability to sleep at night through a drawdown.

The analytical side of investing, picking the right stock, gets most of the attention, but a stock pick can be correct and still get sold at the wrong time if the holder needs that money to live on and watches it fall 75%.

Very few people have the wherewithal to hold through that kind of decline when their livelihood depends on the outcome.

The goal is not to test whether a person can endure that kind of pain and come out the other side.

The goal is to avoid that circumstance altogether.

A person whose near-term personal and family financial needs are already covered can hold an investment account through a 75% drawdown without becoming a forced seller, since nothing requires pulling that money out at the worst possible moment.

Without that cushion, the pressure of needing the money or simply the emotional toll of the decline is likely to force a sale, even for someone convinced in advance that it would not happen to them.

Beating the Market Is an Outcome, Not a Process.

Whether an investor beats the market in a given stretch is an outcome, not a process, and there is no process that reliably produces that outcome.

What does exist is a process for investing itself: researching stocks, estimating what their returns are likely to be on a probabilistic basis.

That process still says nothing about what the broader market will do, or whether the stocks selected will end up ahead of it.

A personal hurdle rate of at least 10% is a common target when evaluating a stock, independent of whether the market ends up above or below that figure.

There is no reliable way to know in advance whether the market will outperform or underperform a given hurdle rate, and no dependable method exists for modeling stock market returns more broadly.

The economy typically grows around 3% in a good year, while stocks have historically averaged about 9% annual returns.

That difference comes from two sources over time: 1) corporate profits rising as a share of the overall economy, and 2) the valuation multiple investors apply to those profits also expanding.

Both of those forces are essentially unknowable in advance.

Being able to predict the multiple investors will assign to future earnings would also mean being able to predict interest rates, since rates are a major input into that multiple, and at that point an investor would do better simply trading on anticipated Federal Reserve moves directly.

That unpredictability is the real reason beating the market should not be the goal: the market's actual return is not something an investor can reliably know ahead of time.

What an investor can control is the hurdle rate used to evaluate a potential investment, the minimum return required to justify making it.

Stock markets have historically returned around 9% to 10%, which is why many investors adopt something close to that figure as their hurdle rate.

An investor targeting stocks expected to return 12% to 13% has a good chance of beating the market over the long term, provided that estimate turns out to be correct.

Framed that way, the goal is not to beat the market directly but to meet a chosen hurdle rate, and beating the market becomes a byproduct of setting that hurdle rate high enough and being right about the underlying picks, not a goal pursued on its own terms.

Meeting a hurdle rate does not guarantee beating the market in any given stretch.

History includes periods where a handful of stocks entered a major index and gained a couple hundred percent within just a couple of years, climbs that a disciplined, conservative analysis at the time would have had little basis to anticipate, and that sometimes took another couple of years to revert afterward.

This is not commentary on any particular period happening now; it describes a pattern that has recurred historically and helps explain why an investor cannot simply decide to beat the market.

What an investor can focus on instead is an individual benchmark, a personal hurdle rate, and whether that rate gets met.

An investor can decide what hurdle rate to apply and work toward meeting it, which is a fundamentally different exercise than trying to outguess where the broader index ends up.

For More on Stop Trying to Beat the Market, check out the video below.

video previewSubscribe Stop Trying to Beat the Market Website Version

YouTube FAQ

Nothing in this newsletter is investment advice nor should be construed as such. Contributors to the newsletter may own securities discussed. Furthermore, accounts contributors advise on may also have positions in companies discussed. Please see our full disclaimers here.