Are You Investing in the Wrong Retirement Accounts?
Get smarter on investing, business, and personal finance in 5 minutes.
If you were forwarded this email, click here to subscribe for freeThis newsletter is adapted from a previous video Drew Cohen did on Retirement Accounts.
Two people made the same investments, earned the same investment returns, and set aside the same amount of take-home pay toward savings.
After 40 years, one of them had $4 million and the other had $2.9 million.
A person might assume the one with $4 million came out ahead.
That assumption would be wrong.
The person with $2.9 million actually spent more than $250,000 more in after-tax money over the rest of their life than the person with $4 million.
The difference came down to which investment account each person used and the tax treatment built into each one.
In this week’s Five Minute Money, we will cover all the types of accounts you can invest in including; taxable accounts, tax-deferred accounts, and tax-free accounts, along with the specific features of the main account types, and 5 rules for deciding which accounts to use.
With that, let’s begin!
Three Account Types.
There are three general account types: taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-free.
A taxable account is a standard investment brokerage account, the kind offered by Charles Schwab, Fidelity, or Robinhood.
Money goes in after tax, and there are no special tax benefits inside the account: trading activity, dividends, and capital gains all receive ordinary tax treatment as they occur.
Withdrawals from a taxable account are not taxed again, since the money was already taxed before it went in.
A person might assume this is obvious, on the logic that withdrawing money that was already taxed should not trigger another tax bill, and for a taxable account, that assumption holds.
That absence of restrictions also means a taxable account carries no contribution limit and no penalty for an early withdrawal, a flexibility advantage worth keeping in mind when comparing account types for a goal with a shorter time horizon than retirement.
This detail matters more than it first appears.
Many people planning for retirement focus only on the total dollar figure they believe they need and skip over the tax treatment of the account that money sits in.
If the full amount needed for retirement sits in a taxable account, withdrawals come out tax-free.
If that same amount sits in a tax-deferred account such as an IRA, withdrawals get taxed as ordinary income.
A target of $4 million is typically treated as an after-tax figure, so the account type holding that $4 million changes how much of it is actually available to spend.
In the opening scenario, the person with $2.9 million held an after-tax account and owed nothing on withdrawals, while the person with $4 million held a pre-tax account and owed ordinary income tax on every withdrawal, which is why that person ended up with less spendable money in the end.
This gap between a retirement number and what it is actually worth after tax is easy to overlook, since a dollar figure on its own says nothing about who ultimately claims a share of it in taxes.
A tax-deferred account, such as a traditional IRA, means no taxes are owed on activity inside the account until money actually leaves it.
Dividends received inside the account are not a taxable event.
Capital gains from selling a holding inside the account are not a taxable event either.
Only withdrawals get taxed, and they get taxed later, as ordinary income.
A tax-free account, such as a Roth IRA, works differently: money goes in after tax, nothing inside the account is ever taxed, and withdrawals are not taxed either.
The Core Retirement Accounts.
The 401(k).
The two most common retirement accounts are the 401(k) and the IRA.
A 401(k) is employer-sponsored, offered through a person's company, and contributions are made with pre-tax dollars.
The 2026 contribution limit is $24,500, a figure that applies specifically to a person's own contributions and does not include any amount an employer separately contributes on that person's behalf.
A contribution to a 401(k) is deductible, which lowers adjusted gross income and reduces taxes owed for that year.
Money inside a 401(k) grows tax-deferred, so dividends and capital gains inside the account are not taxed as they occur, and withdrawals are generally taxed as ordinary income.
Many employers offer a matching contribution on a 401(k): money the employer adds on top of what an employee contributes, which still belongs to the employee.
Checking for an employer match is worth doing before anything else discussed here, since a match on $24,000 of contributions is effectively an immediate 100% return, a benefit large enough to outweigh most other considerations about which account type to use.
401(k) accounts also include catch-up provisions for savers 50 and older, allowing additional contributions beyond the standard limit, with an even larger catch-up amount available after age 63.
Money inside a 401(k) is generally locked in until retirement or until the account holder turns 59 and a half.
A withdrawal taken before that age faces ordinary income tax plus a 10% penalty.
Traditional IRA.
An IRA works similarly to a 401(k) but with a much lower contribution limit, $7,500 for 2026.
A detail often glossed over online is that holding both a 401(k) and an IRA does not automatically mean a person can deduct contributions to both.
If a person already participates in a 401(k), the ability to deduct IRA contributions phases out based on income.
For 2026, that phase-out begins at $81,000 of income for single filers and $129,000 for joint filers, and it fully phases out about $10,000 above that threshold.
Once fully phased out, a contribution to a traditional IRA earns no tax deduction at all, which raises an obvious question: what is the point of contributing to it in that case?
For most people in that position, there is no good reason to do so, unless the backdoor Roth strategy described below happens to apply.
There is one answer, tied to a strategy called the backdoor Roth IRA, covered in more detail below.
Aside from that strategy, both the 401(k) and the IRA share the same basic shape: pre-tax contributions, tax-deferred growth, and ordinary income tax on withdrawal.
Both are retirement accounts, meaning neither offers easy access to that money for something like a home purchase before retirement age.
Roth 401(k) and Roth IRA.
Both the 401(k) and the IRA have a Roth version.
Whether an employer offers a Roth 401(k) depends on that employer's plan.
A Roth account flips the tax treatment: contributions are made with after-tax dollars, so there is no deduction when the money goes in, but withdrawals in retirement are not taxed.
A traditional 401(k) provides a deduction going in and taxes the withdrawal; a Roth 401(k) provides no deduction going in and taxes nothing on the way out.
A general rule follows from this: a person who expects a higher tax rate in the future benefits more from putting money into after-tax accounts today.
The Roth IRA differs from the traditional IRA in one additional way: it carries an income limit that blocks contributions entirely above a certain threshold.
For 2026, that phase-out begins around $153,000 for single filers and $242,000 for joint filers, and a person earning above the top of that range cannot contribute to a Roth IRA directly.
The Backdoor Roth IRA.
This is where the IRA deduction phase-out connects to the Roth IRA income limit.
A person who earns too much to deduct a traditional IRA contribution, and too much to contribute directly to a Roth IRA, can still contribute to a traditional IRA without taking the deduction, then convert that balance into a Roth IRA.
This is called a backdoor Roth IRA, and it gives a high earner a way into a Roth account despite being phased out of contributing to one directly.
The strategy works because the tax code does not restrict who can convert an existing IRA balance into a Roth IRA, even though it does restrict who can contribute to a Roth IRA directly.
A conversion from a pre-tax account like a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA is a taxable event: the converted amount counts as ordinary income for that year.
A person does this because they expect to sit in a higher tax bracket later on, which makes paying tax on the conversion now, at a comparatively lower rate, worthwhile.
The same type of conversion can apply to a 401(k) as well, converting it to a Roth 401(k).
These conversions tend to make the most sense during a year of unusually low income, such as a stretch between jobs, since whatever gets converted is taxed at that year's lower income level.
A partial conversion done during such a year, moved into a Roth IRA or Roth 401(k), can produce a meaningfully better outcome than the same conversion done in a typical income year.
Solo 401(k) and SEP IRA.
Two further accounts are worth knowing, even without going deep into either one: the solo 401(k) and the SEP IRA, both designed for self-employed individuals.
These accounts allow considerably higher contribution limits than a standard IRA.
The solo 401(k) limit is $72,000 for 2026.
The SEP IRA limit is the lesser of $72,000 or 25% of eligible income.
The same tax logic covered above, choosing between pre-tax and after-tax treatment, applies to these accounts as well, even though the specific contribution figures differ from a standard 401(k) or IRA.
Two Other Tax-Advantaged Accounts.
The HSA.
The HSA is often described as triple tax advantaged.
A contribution earns a federal tax deduction going in, the same basic mechanism as a 401(k) or traditional IRA contribution, the money grows tax-deferred while inside the account, and withdrawals used for qualified medical expenses are not taxed at all.
A handful of states, notably California and New Jersey, do not follow this federal treatment and still tax HSA earnings at the state level, an added wrinkle worth knowing for residents of those states.
The HSA works well as a way to cover medical spending specifically, though it comes with some friction: setting one up can be administratively annoying, and investment options inside an HSA are often more limited than inside a typical brokerage account.
A withdrawal used for something other than qualified medical care before age 65 faces a 20% penalty on top of ordinary income tax.
After 65, that penalty goes away, though ordinary income tax still applies to non-medical withdrawals.
What counts as qualified medical spending is broader than most people expect.
Savers have successfully used HSA funds on items such as supplements and protein powder, categories that can technically qualify as medical expenses, which gives the account more flexibility than its name suggests, though it is worth confirming what qualifies before committing money to it.
The 529 Plan.
The 529 plan is built for a specific purpose: saving for a child's college tuition and related education costs.
A few different vehicles exist for this kind of saving, but the 529 plan stands out because of how much money it allows a family to set aside.
There is no federal contribution limit on a 529 plan, which makes it a genuinely powerful savings vehicle, though contributing too much in a single year can trigger gift tax consequences.
For 2026, a donor can contribute up to $19,000 per year before that applies, or $38,000 per child for a married couple contributing jointly.
That is a substantial amount, enough that starting early with contributions at that level creates a real risk of overfunding the account relative to actual future tuition costs.
Maxing out contributions at that level is not necessarily the right move for every family; the appropriate amount depends heavily on how old a child already is when saving begins.
Contributions to a 529 plan are made after tax, with no deduction going in, but the money grows tax-deferred inside the account, and withdrawals used for qualified education expenses, including tuition and other ancillary costs, are not taxed at all.
Money withdrawn for anything other than qualified education expenses faces a 10% penalty in addition to ordinary income tax on the earnings portion.
Five Rules for Choosing Which Accounts to Use.
Rule One: Where Will Your Tax Rate Head?
The first rule is to consider whether a person's tax rate will likely be higher or lower in the future.
A higher expected future tax rate favors using after-tax accounts now, since paying tax today at a lower rate beats paying it later at a higher one.
A lower expected future tax rate favors pre-tax accounts now.
A person earning $250,000 a year today who expects retirement income limited mostly to Social Security and modest investment income, sitting in a noticeably lower bracket, benefits from maxing out a pre-tax 401(k) and taking the deduction now, since the tax savings today outweigh the tax owed later at that lower future rate.
To put it simply, a lower tax bracket today paired with an expected higher bracket later favors after-tax accounts, while a higher tax bracket today paired with an expected lower bracket later favors pre-tax accounts.
Rule Two: Use Roth Accounts in Lower-Income Years.
A Roth conversion also makes sense specifically in a year when taxable income drops for some reason, whether through a job change, a gap in employment, or any other temporary dip, since converting pre-tax money to post-tax money during that lower-income window means paying conversion tax at a lower rate than usual.
This same lower-income window is also when a Roth conversion tends to work best for someone using the backdoor Roth strategy described earlier, since the income used to judge the conversion is lower for that year specifically.
Rule Three: Do Not Forget Retirement Income.
A person's salary may disappear at retirement, but Social Security counts as taxable income, investment income counts as taxable income, and rental income counts as taxable income.
A spouse who has not yet retired adds income to the household.
Many people do not fully stop working either, picking up part-time work or consulting income instead.
In the opening scenario, the person with $2.9 million held all of that money in after-tax accounts and saved heavily during years when their tax bracket was still low, with income rising through promotions over time.
That same person also kept earning some income after retirement, through part-time work, consulting, and Social Security, which meant a pre-tax account would have added even more to an already meaningful taxable income base.
Expected income after retirement, together with the total amount saved, is what determines which account type actually works out best.
The intro scenario turns on exactly this distinction: the person with $4 million appeared to have more on paper, but once ordinary income tax on a pre-tax account got layered on top of an already meaningful retirement income base, from part-time work, consulting, and Social Security, the after-tax saver came out ahead in actual spendable dollars.
Rule Four: Diversify Across Account Types.
Future income and future tax brackets are both genuinely hard to predict decades in advance, especially for someone saving in their 20s or 30s.
Holding a mix of Roth and pre-tax accounts prepares for more than one outcome.
A high earner already sitting in the top tax bracket is a clear exception, since an all pre-tax approach typically makes more sense in that case, but most savers fall somewhere in the middle, where either direction could plausibly turn out to be correct.
Tax brackets themselves can also change over time, independent of a person's own income, through changes to the tax code itself, which adds another reason to spread savings across both pre-tax and after-tax accounts instead of committing everything to one outcome.
Rule Five: Weigh Flexibility.
The fifth rule is flexibility, which comes in two forms.
The first is investment selection: a 401(k) often limits the investment choices available compared with a brokerage account or an IRA, and fees inside a 401(k) plan can run higher too.
The tax benefits and any employer match still make using a 401(k) worthwhile despite that limitation.
A rollover into an IRA can sometimes happen while still employed, if the specific plan allows it, though it typically happens after leaving the employer entirely.
Done properly, a rollover does not trigger a taxable event, and it opens up a far wider set of investment options once the balance moves into an IRA.
The second form of flexibility is access: money saved for a goal like a home down payment should not sit inside a 401(k) or an IRA, since pulling it out before retirement age brings penalties and taxes that defeat the purpose of saving for that goal in the first place.
Now you know how each investment account works and when to use each one.
For More on Retirement Accounts, check out the video below.
YouTube FAQ
Nothing in this newsletter is investment advice nor should be construed as such. Contributors to the newsletter may own securities discussed. Furthermore, accounts contributors advise on may also have positions in companies discussed. Please see our full disclaimers here.